Versus! Walk-Behind Trenchers Vs Stand-On Skid Steers with Trencher Attachments

A trencher attachment on a Ditch Witch stand-on skid steer

When deciding between a walk-behind trencher and a stand-on skid steer with a trencher attachment, the key is to evaluate the specific demands of the job at hand. For straightforward, quick trenching tasks, a walk-behind trencher is typically the optimal choice, offering efficiency and simplicity. However, the versatility and increasing popularity of stand-on skid steers with a trencher attachment make them invaluable for a broader scope of landscaping and installation work. Understanding the distinct advantages and constraints of each option is crucial for operator safety, job efficiency and overall productivity.

Trenching for Efficiency

When choosing the right equipment for the jobsite, it’s important to consider the nature of the project. Does the project require versatility, or would a single-purpose machine get the job done? If the latter, you should consider a walk-behind trencher. The walk-behind trencher’s dedicated chain, teeth and sprocket combination are specifically designed to work together to make trenching as efficient as possible. If your goal is to minimize time and labor on the jobsite, this powerhouse is your go-to solution. It’s specifically designed to tackle trench-intensive tasks with ease, whether you’re laying plumbing, irrigation lines, water pipes or other utilities.

Enhanced Versatility

If trenching is just one of several capabilities you want in a piece of equipment, operators should consider choosing a stand-on skid steer with a trencher attachment. This machine is an ideal fit for jobs that only require a trench of around 50 yds and/or a jobsite that will have a range of tasks. For example, if a job will require not only trenching, but backfilling, moving utilities or putting a yard back together, a stand-on skid steer will be the right choice due to its versatile nature. With the ability to effortlessly switch attachments through an automated latching system, operators can efficiently jump from one project to the next. From a trencher to a bucket, auger or fork, operators can benefit from the versatility these machines offer and handle countless tasks with ease. Its increased maneuverability and visibility provide operators with an unobstructed view of the jobsite, helping boost productivity when working in residential, space-restricted areas where obstacle avoidance is necessary.

Assessing Jobsite Demands

A dedicated Ditch Witch trencher digging dirt.

While each machine has its own unique function and specific role on the jobsite, knowing the best situation to use each machine is essential for jobsite success. If you need a machine that will effectively and efficiently cut a trench, then a walk-behind trenching machine is the ideal solution. This machine is a cost-effective option that will quickly enhance your ROI. However, if your jobs extend beyond trench cutting and include tasks like debris and landscape management, the versatility of stand-on skid steers will be the most beneficial.

Brant Kukuk is the compact equipment product marketing manager at Ditch Witch.

Utility vehicles are perfectly made for both work and play. Learn all about these sweet rides here.